Why You Shouldn’t Convert to a Roth IRA
Wednesday, September 1st, 2010I recently spoke with fee-only financial advisor Bob Wilgo, who was complaining about the hype of Roth conversions and why people should not convert from a traditional IRA to a tax-free Roth. Here are his top 3 reasons when he advises clients:
1. The tax bite is too big. Does it make sense to convert? The number one question you should ask is: Where are you are going to get the money to pay the tax owed today for the benefit of tax-free growth tomorrow? With the economic downturn, people simply don’t have the money to pay the taxes up front or even over the next two years.
2. Retirement is too close. The problem here is it could take a long time to recoup the tax paid today for tax-free growth of a Roth. If you’re close to retiring, converting does not make sense.
3. Tax brackets change in retirement. Chances are that you will be in a lower tax bracket when you start taking distributions out of your IRA. Very few people have as much income in retirement as they do in the height of their working years.
The list above contains a few things to consider before you do a Roth conversion. Either way, you should consider a self-directed IRA—whether you are investing with tax-deferred or tax-free dollars—to acquire alternative investments that you know, understand, and have control over. For more information on how a self-directed IRA works, visit www.theentrustgroup.com.